A Message Board, Guestbook, or Poll hosted for your website.
A community forum for the discussion of ethics and progressive ideas

New Posts
 
New York Bird Club > Forums > General/Wildlife Conservation > Animal Abuse for Ducks Found at Green Meadows Farm, Queens
 
 


Thread Tools Search This Thread 
Reply
 
Author Comment
 
luciedove
    11/19/09 at 11:27 AMReply with quote#1

The following email from Caroline Lee was sent to us.  It is a letter sent to the ASPCA who is not responding and has done nothing as of yet.  Please contact the ASPCA, Green Meadows Farm and any other organizations and agencies that can help the ducks.
 
ASPCA once again is ignoring these poor birds.  They had an inspector out a few days ago...never noticed or mentioned these poor ducklings/chicks.
 
I am writing to ask you take immediate action investigating Green Meadows Farm.
 
info@visitgreenmeadowsfarm.com
718-470-0224
Green Meadows Farm,
7350 Little Neck Pkwy,
Glen Oaks, NY 11004
 
I visited Green Meadows Farm on November 15, 2009, and was horrified by what I saw. The conditions I witnessed were inexcusably cruel and inhumane with many animals denied both water and shelter.  Green Meadows had on display newly hatched baby ducklings and baby chicks in open air wire pens, with no protection from drafts or cold weather. According to every duck care authority, including Cornell University Duck Research Laboratory, " If ducklings are hatched artificially, rather than by a broody duck, the caretaker must provide the newly hatched ducklings with a warm dry brooding area free of drafts..."
 
Cornell Duck Research Laboratory further delineates specific temperatures under which ducklings must be raised.  Not only were these ducklings and chicks at Green Meadows Farm exposed to drafts with no protection whatsoever, they were also exposed to temperatures greater than 40 degrees below the mandated temperatures at which these birds must be maintained.  In addition, none of the ducklings' waterers were filled, and the ducklings, which should have access to water 24/7, had no water.  The wire flooring for their pens was much to wide, causing damage and injury to their feet.  There was no staff supervision at any of the duckling stations and children were permitted to handle these very fragile ducklings and chicks without any guidance or education.   
 
The pen that housed the 3-6 week old ducklings also was made of wire, once again providing no protection from drafts.  There was no heat source in their pen.  The pen housed 40-50 ducklings and far exceeded the recommended mandates for space required per duck.  Many of these ducklings were shivering, with obvious respiratory and other illnesses, eye infections, no feathers, and were too weak to move.   
Green Meadows Farm should not be permitted to display ducklings in open wire pens.  It is cruel and exposes them to weather conditions they are not equipped to handle.  It is incomprehensible that these birds are left out in open wire pens at any time of year.  The fact that Green Meadows has them outside in November shows a complete disregard for the welfare and well-being of these birds.   
 
The adult ducks housed in a separate muddy pen, did not have clean water and their water bowl was not deep enough for them to dip their entire bills, a basic requirement for adult waterfowl.
 
The goose pen was also grossly inadequate.  The geese were forced into a small filthy muddy area.  The waterer used for the geese contained dirty water and was not deep enough for them to dip their bills.
 
In addition to the horrible conditions under which these birds were kept, I documented multiple abuses of other animals and would be glad to provide you with photos of the horrific conditions to which all these poor creatures were subjected. 
 
I am demanding an immediate inspection be made of Green Meadows Farm and that you send me a copy of your written inspection report.   It is my understanding that you recently inspected Green Meadows Farm.  I am extremely disturbed that these gross abuses were seemingly ignored by you and no violations were issued for these obvious acts of animal cruelty.

 
Sincerely,
Caroline A. Lee
Attorney At Law
43-60 Douglaston Parkway
Suite 522
Douglaston, NY 11363
 
Arlene
    11/19/09 at 01:16 PMReply with quote#2

I don't know why anyone even bothers to contact the ASPCA, since they do virtually nothing in almost every single matter in which they are asked to help.  Frankly, there needs to be a grassroots campaign calling out the ASPCA on their lack of compassion and assistance.  Seems to me there have been enough scandals at this organization, at the top leadership level, that their credibility is in the toilet.

Having said that, I would document by video the conditions at this farm and post it on YouTube, MySpace and any other site you can think of.  I would also contact the TV news stations and newspapers in the area and ask them to do a feature on this - in other words, get this out from hiding and let the public see what is going on.  Wouldn't hurt to get a bunch of people together for a protest right outside this place ~ needs to be more than just 10 people and not raggedly-looking (you want to be taken seriously, not look like a small bunch of loonies). 

You could also get the "big guns" involved - PETA, Humane Society, Humane Farming, and hey, ducks and geese - United Poultry Concerns!  Get everyone on this case.

And as a lawyer, couldn't Ms. Lee file some sort of suit against this place?  How about contacting ALDF - Animal Legal Defense Fund? 

Shoot as many arrows into the sky as possible - at least one or two of them will hit a target that will DO something.

Sometimes one determined individual can accomplish more than any half-assed group. 


 
 Never underestimate the power of a small group of thoughtful people to change the world. Indeed, it's the only thing that ever has.
Margaret Mead
Roberta Schiff
    11/19/09 at 02:41 PMReply with quote#3

Sad, but not unexpected. I assume these ducks are being hatched to be raised and slaughtered for food. Thus they are considered commodities, rather than animals. Although if they were, say curing valuable hardwood, they probably would not expose it to the elements. Sometimes it is hard to connect with our fellow humans.

















Catherine Martin-Miller
    11/19/09 at 04:49 PMReply with quote#4

did Caroline call or just write to the ASPCA?
Report Cruelty:
(212) 876-7700, ext. 4450

Marilyn
    11/19/09 at 05:16 PMReply with quote#5

I think Ms Lee's request for a copy of ASPCA's report on Green Meadow Farm is the way to go.  This is also a case of every day that passes, this cruelty continues and it's horrible these tiny things are left to suffer like that.

To get media attention for this is most important,  copy of Ms Lee's letter should definitely perk the ears of a some reporter for newspaper or tv news and Arlene's suggestion for a You Tube video follow-up, is really good.  What Green Meadow is doing is disgusting and it needs to be publicized.  The worthlessness of the ASPCA needs to be continually publicized too.
luciedove
    11/19/09 at 06:03 PMReply with quote#6

We have received a reply from the A.S.P.C.A. as follows:
 
Hello,

We have received Ms. Lee's complaint and have dispatched agents to the location in Queens.  We take every complaint of animal cruelty very seriously and will do so with this case as well.  Thank you for your concern,  as we all care about the well being of animals in need.  The results of the investigation will be relayed to Ms. Lee as she is the complainant on this case.  

Take care
 
Annemarie Lucas
Supervisory Special Investigator
Humane Law Enforcement
 
ASPCA®
424 East 92nd Street
New York, NY 10128
 
annemariel@aspca.org
 
P: 212 876-7700 x 4455
C: 646 208-3877
F: 212 534-8888
http://www.aspca.org

Richard W. Firth
    11/20/09 at 10:23 AMReply with quote#7

Green Meadows Farm,
7350 Little Neck Pkwy,
Glen Oaks, NY 11004
 
I am writing you about a situation by a visitor to your farm which is immediately described below:
 
"I visited Green Meadows Farm on November 15, 2009, and was horrified by what I saw. The conditions I witnessed were inexcusably cruel and inhumane with many animals denied both water and shelter.  Green Meadows had on display newly hatched baby ducklings and baby chicks in open air wire pens, with no protection from drafts or cold weather. According to every duck care authority, including Cornell University Duck Research Laboratory, " If ducklings are hatched artificially, rather than by a broody duck, the caretaker must provide the newly hatched ducklings with a warm dry brooding area free of drafts..."
 
Cornell Duck Research Laboratory further delineates specific temperatures under which ducklings must be raised.  Not only were these ducklings and chicks at Green Meadows Farm exposed to drafts with no protection whatsoever, they were also exposed to temperatures greater than 40 degrees below the mandated temperatures at which these birds must be maintained.  In addition, none of the ducklings' waterers were filled, and the ducklings, which should have access to water 24/7, had no water.  The wire flooring for their pens was much to wide, causing damage and injury to their feet.  There was no staff supervision at any of the duckling stations and children were permitted to handle these very fragile ducklings and chicks without any guidance or education.   
 
The pen that housed the 3-6 week old ducklings also was made of wire, once again providing no protection from drafts.  There was no heat source in their pen.  The pen housed 40-50 ducklings and far exceeded the recommended mandates for space required per duck.  Many of these ducklings were shivering, with obvious respiratory and other illnesses, eye infections, no feathers, and were too weak to move. 
  
Green Meadows Farm should not be permitted to display ducklings in open wire pens.  It is cruel and exposes them to weather conditions they are not equipped to handle.  It is incomprehensible that these birds are left out in open wire pens at any time of year.  The fact that Green Meadows has them outside in November shows a complete disregard for the welfare and well-being of these birds.   
 
The adult ducks housed in a separate muddy pen, did not have clean water and their water bowl was not deep enough for them to dip their entire bills, a basic requirement for adult waterfowl.
 
The goose pen was also grossly inadequate.  The geese were forced into a small filthy muddy area.  The waterer used for the geese contained dirty water and was not deep enough for them to dip their bills.
 
In addition to the horrible conditions under which these birds were kept, I documented multiple abuses of other animals and would be glad to provide you with photos of the horrific conditions to which all these poor creatures were subjected.  
 
I am extremely disturbed that these gross abuses were seemingly ignored by you and no violations were issued for these obvious acts of animal cruelty."
 
I demand you correct the abuses listed above.  Don't take this matter lightly as I am in Virginia and this situation is going across the nation to bring pressure on you to end this abuse.  I am sending copies of this e-mail to PETA, Fund for Animals, U. S. Humane Society asking them to put pressure on you.
 
The above alert came to me from New York Bird Club.
 
Sincerely,
 
Richard W. Firth
Mechanicsville, Virginia 23116

IY
    11/20/09 at 06:37 PMReply with quote#8

I DONATE MONTHLY TO ASPCA, AS WELL AS 9 OTHER ORGs. FOCUSING ON ANIMALS/ENVIRONMENT. I CALLED ASPCA ABOUT GREEN MEADOWS AND THEY SAID THEY HAD INVESTIGATED, AND THERE WERE NO VIOLATIONS.

WHAT TO DO
I HAVE HAD DISAPPOINTING RESULTS WITH ASPCA, REGARDING REPORTING OBVIOUS ANIMAL ABUSES.  AS I AM NOT ABLE TO SEE FOR MYSELF, I CANNOT SAY IN THIS CASE,THOUGH I WOULD NOT DOUBT IT.
IF I FIND MORE SITUATIONS OVERLOOKED I SHALL CALL TO CANCEL MY $ SUPPORT, THOUGH I HATE TO DO SO, BUT JUST TO MAKE A POINT, MAYBE MANY PEOPLE SHOULD THREATEN TO CANCEL FINANCIAL SUPPORT IF ACTIONS ARE NOT TAKEN.

luciedove
    11/22/09 at 10:10 AMReply with quote#9

We have received a response from Caroline Lee with regard to the ASPCA investigation of Green Meadows Farm Petting Zoo as follows: 

Hi Anna,
 
I was at the zoo again yesterday.  The display with 50-60 sick 3-6 week old ducklings was gone.  I was told they removed all those ducks immediately after my visit Sunday.  I doubt these ducklings were there when the A made their visit. 
 
Additionally, the  7 - 8 open-air cages of 1-3 week old ducklings/chicks, is now reduced to 3 open-air cages. On Sunday there were more than 100 ducklings/chicks...I suspect GM culled the sick ones and consolidated the remaining ones, because there are not even close to that number now.   Of course there is no way to prove what happened to them.
 
The pen with the adult ducks had more than 30 on Sunday...yesterday 24. 
 
So, the agents from the A did not see all I saw.
 
That being said, I do not believe the A is correct in their findings.  When the A visited GM, 3 open air cages containing newly hatched ducklings (some a bit older... up to 2 weeks old) were still on display.  It was cold and pouring rain on these ducklings/chicks at the time the A was there.  Dr Corey claims the A can only act when they see sick, injured, or dead animals.  She claims the A has no authority to tell anyone to provide food, water, and shelter, and unless their agents actually see sick/injured/dead animals, they will not take any action or even issue a warning.  I do not agree with her interpretation of the A's authority.  I read the cruelty statute as granting the A express authority to enforce all laws to protect animals... all animals and §353  says there has to be proper sustenance, food and drink. [sustenance defined as the: The supporting of life or health; maintenance]. Or in anyway furthers any act of cruelty, a catch all that would cover lack of shelter.
 
Additionally, at the time of the A's visit, the GM vet had in his possession one of the sick ducklings from Sunday's overcrowded display w/50-60 ducklings.   (During my Sunday visit I asked the vet to accompany me to the duck pen and pointed out the many sick ducklings)   According to GM's own vet, at the time he took the duckling, she was suffering from dehydration and was unable to walk more than a few steps.   From my own observations, the duck also was suffering from respiratory illness, eye infections, and no feather integrity whatsoever.  When I asked Dr Corey why this didn't qualify as a sick duckling for which they could cite GM for animal cruelty, she stated that since the vet had the duck, GM had gotten the duck care, which was all they needed to do.  The fact that the duck was dehydrated because GM did not supply water in this display, couldn't walk because the pen was so overcrowded and she was malnourished, and was so sick overall due to lack of shelter and care, according to Dr Corey was not relevant because the duckling was now under a vet's care. 
 
The GM vet contacted me after my visit to the farm.  He stated to me that he thought the animals needed a better regulatory system to oversee them.    The fact that GM's own vet felt they needed to be better regulated speaks volumes.
 
So, short answer to your question...I disagree with the A's findings.  Ducklings are entitled to shelter and water and when the A sees animals that are without these basic necessities, I think they have a duty and an obligation to act. 
 

 


Patrice
    11/23/09 at 12:00 PMReply with quote#10

This Green Meadow Farm has been trouble for a long time. When my kids were in elementary school, there was a class trip for my older daughter. I went and was horrified. It is basically a petting zoo mill where school trips from all over the city come to see farm animals. There is little supervision and these animals, goats, sheep, lambs and cows are tugged and abused by kids that don't know any better. Kids line up to milk the cow by the hundreds. It's really a shame. When 2 years later it was time for my second daughter to make the trip, I said "no way". The teacher called me and acted like I was some kind of a nut and told me she felt sorry that I wasn't going to let my daughter go, that she would have to stay in another class for the day and that I was wrong to make her miss out on this trip. I told her I felt it was cruel and that I couldn't believe that she thought this trip was good for kids. We went round and round and I stuck to my guns. I hope that Animal welfare groups stay on this place and shut them down.

Previous Thread | Next Thread
Reply

  Bookmarks  
Digg Diggdel.icio.us del.icio.usStumbleUpon StumbleUponGoogle GoogleTwitter Twitter
Facebook FacebookWindows Live Favorites Windows Live FavoritesTechnorati Tags Technorati Tagsreddit reddit

communication: bestbirdclub@yahoo.com
disclaimer: we do not verify the accuracy of your posting and assume no responsibility for its content.