A Message Board, Guestbook, or Poll hosted for your website.
A community forum for the discussion of ethics and progressive ideas

New Posts
 
New York Bird Club > Forums > Rehoming/Sanctuaries & Shelters > ASPCA issues statement on euthanasia of Oreo (thrown off a 6th floor rooftop)
 
 


Thread Tools Search This Thread 
Reply
 
Author Comment
 
dogs have rights too
    11/13/09 at 03:14 PMReply with quote#1

ASPCA logo for printer

Press Release

 

ASPCA Issues Statement on Euthanasia of Oreo

 

November 13, 2009

ASPCA Media Contact
http://www.aspca.org/pressroom/press-releases/111309.html

NEW YORK— The ASPCA® (The American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals®) issued a statement from President and CEO Ed Sayres prompted by today's euthanasia of Oreo, a victim of animal cruelty:

On June 18th, a one-year old Pit Bull Mix named Oreo was thrown off a 6th floor Brooklyn roof top by 19-year old Fabian Henderson.  Oreo sustained two broken legs and a fractured rib in the horrific incident.  Amidst a flurry of media coverage and public outcry, Oreo was taken to the ASPCA hospital to be treated for her injuries, and Mr. Henderson was placed under arrest by ASPCA Humane Law Enforcement Agents. 

The circumstances that led to this most difficult and heartbreaking of decisions are not widely known.  In fact, details such as these are usually closely guarded.  And yet, what is even more tragic about this story's ending is that it is an all-too-familiar outcome in shelters across the country. 

It is the true face of the fight against animal cruelty.

Oreo was a victim of cruelty at the hands of Mr. Henderson.  The details surrounding these incidents are largely unknown.  However, after Mr. Henderson's arrest in July, it was learned that several of his neighbors reported hearing the sounds of the dog being beaten for at least 20-30 minutes—and the dog whimpering as a consequence.

After arriving at the ASPCA's facility, Oreo began to recuperate from her injuries, only to begin showing signs of extreme aggression—with little provocation or warning.  As is customary at the ASPCA, the dog underwent a series of comprehensive behavior evaluations.  This evaluation system has been used to assess many other dogs and is used to determine the rehabilitation programs needed to prepare them for foster care or placement.  In the case of Oreo, we also sought the assessment of an outside veterinary behaviorist.  The outcomes of these evaluations were all the same:  the dog was not able to be placed in a home.  Despite extensive behavior rehabilitation efforts undertaken by ASPCA staff, Oreo continued to lunge, growl, snap and attempt to bite.   She would lunge at a behaviorist, only to spontaneously and unpredictably redirect her aggression toward her handler.   She could not be socialized with other dogs for fear of an attack—her aggression toward other dogs was clearly evident during her evaluations.  For the safety of the individuals at the ASPCA, the other animals, and Oreo herself, she had to be kept in relative isolation, and daily contact with her was kept to a minimum of essential, and highly-trained, personnel.  In fact, employees were even directed to refrain from making sustained eye contact with Oreo so as to not incite aggression. 

Because adoption was not an option, the ASPCA looked at placing Oreo in a long-term resident facility.  However, because of the aggressive behavior displayed, it is almost certain that Oreo would have lived out her entire life in seclusion from other dogs and people.   Her contact with the outside world would have been minimal at best.  Her quality of life would have been reduced to virtually nothing.  Thus, we arrived at the painful yet clear decision to humanely euthanize Oreo.

While Oreo's plight has garnered a plethora of media attention due to the sensational nature of her injuries, the decision to euthanize her is not a novel one.  These are decisions that we have had to make before—and will undoubtedly have to make again.  And as painful as these choices are, they are the same ones that face dedicated shelter workers throughout the country each and every day.   However, these outcomes are made all the more tragic because they are often preventable.

Animals that suffer cruelty at the hands of their owners often face tragedy beyond that which they have already endured.  Animals like Oreo are abused every day.  These cases often don't make headlines; in fact, most people don't even know this abuse is quietly occurring in their backyard.  But this abuse is all too frequent, and despite more rigorous efforts by law enforcement across the country, shows little sign of completely abating.

Sometimes these animals are fortunate enough to escape the confines of their abuse and are placed in loving homes.  Sometimes, they die as a result of the abuse.  And sometimes they retaliate from their abuse in the only way they know how: aggression.  It is this last unfortunate circumstance that places shelters in the precarious position in which we find ourselves now.  We have done everything humanly possible to save Oreo's life; yet, as a result of the abuse she suffered at the hands of Mr. Henderson, or for other reasons we may never know, she has come to a place where she can no longer be around people or other animals.  We make this decision—and others like it-- with a heavy heart and a complete understanding that had she been treated with love and respect, Oreo's fate would be much different.

People know that the ASPCA is in the business of saving animals’ lives-- it serves as the very core of our 143 year-old mission.  Yet, the moment this statement is picked up, we will feel the repercussions of the difficult decision we know had to be made.  We will receive angry phone calls… profanity-laced e-mails... and we will likely be vilified by tweeters and bloggers across the country.  And the rallying cry of these missives will all be the same: the ASPCA failed this animal.  If the ASPCA has failed at anything, it is shielding America from the true face of animal cruelty for far too long.  Animal cruelty isn’t pretty and doesn’t always have a happy ending—it is ugly and sad and, ultimately, tragic.  As a community of individuals committed to the welfare of animals, we have to be more proactive and insistent in raising our voices against cruelty—and hope that the nation is ready to listen.

###

Founded in 1866, the ASPCA® (The American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals®) is the first humane organization established in the Americas and serves as the nation’s leading voice for animal welfare. One million supporters strong, the ASPCA’s mission is to provide effective means for the prevention of cruelty to animals throughout the United States. As a 501 [c] [3] not-for-profit corporation, the ASPCA is a national leader in the areas of anti-cruelty, community outreach and animal health services. The ASPCA, which is headquartered in New York City, offers a wide range of programs, including a mobile clinic outreach initiative, its own humane law enforcement team, and a groundbreaking veterinary forensics team and mobile animal CSI unit. For more information, please visit http://www.aspca.org.

  Donate Today Share on Facebook

© 2009 ASPCA. All Rights Reserved.

TotallyDisgustedNewYorker
    11/13/09 at 05:04 PMReply with quote#2

At this point in time, Oreo has been pronounced dead. :-(

Bad press was the only thing left to save the dog, and maybe the ASPCA thinks they are bigger than bad press?

I do not believe we should have dangerously aggressive dogs in our society.

They  pose a menace to both people and other animals.

(So please-do not mistake me as a bleeding heart liberal for dangerous dogs just because I am speaking in defense of Oreo and  how this dog's case was handled.)

However? Something is quite fishy and unsettling about poor Oreo's situation.

Ummmm... from what I heard from certain sources, Oreo was placed in the hands of a trainer that was not exactly *nice*.

Read into it what you will.
( It is pretty obvious to me, what conclusion to draw.)

After Oreo's prior life, with that low life thug that threw Oreo off the building, special handling is needed for any animal that has been subjected to such abuse.

This was just one of many things that were pointed out by sources about what went wrong with the handling of Oreo.

The ASPCA totally failed failed Oreo in the mission to rehabilitate. 

There are also many dogs destroyed by the ASPCA that we never hear about.

Supposedly, they do not have to keep tight records on the dogs they destroy.( I would assume this also means any animal in their possession.)

It is NOT the wonderful, animal saving place that everyone thinks it is.

I learned from prior employees( and this is going back years ago) what kind of corruption goes on. Not everyone there cares about animals either.

Does it sound a lot  like the NYCACC? Yes- it sounds way too similar.

In addition, if you really want to be horrified, go learn about the early history of the ASPCA, where they would put several dogs into a cage and drown them as a method of neat and tidy euth.

Sick... Just sick. 

Oreo died as part of a cover up. 

 Did we expect the ASPCA to admit they screwed up on such a tragic abuse case that got so much press?  NO!

" Bury your mistakes", was their mentality- literally.

How much other unjust stuff goes on that we don't know about or only learn from leaks?

Rest in Peace Oreo- you deserved far better.

sarah
    11/13/09 at 05:18 PMReply with quote#3

How else could they have handled that situation?  Let the dog live and bite other's just not to kill him?  Do you have a better solution?  Have you been bitten or attacked by a dog?  I have.  The dog was damaged in every way.  It's a shame it had to be put down, but that's the way it is. 

Sarah



response to disgusted NY
    11/13/09 at 05:22 PMReply with quote#4

Totally disgusted New Yorker makes a lot of ALLEGATIONS with no substantial evidence.  Stop the Gossiping and state some FACTS if you have any. 
Cynthia
    11/13/09 at 06:02 PMReply with quote#5

Dear Naive AR people,
Stop before you drink every cup of Kool-Aid. Read the ingredients.

Do any of you know how useless the A really is? By now you should, if you have ever called to A to help with a lead on cruelty or other danger to pigeons.

What this org really excels at is doing tear-jerker TV commercials that bring in big donations. Little else.

Witness the treatment of the carriage horses. Try calling the A when you see something wrong. Trust me, they are busy filming TV commercials.

The A's "press release" looks to be written by a 7th-grader, with all of the dripping sarcasm and whining. Talk about paranoia.



Barb Cooley
    11/13/09 at 06:18 PMReply with quote#6

 My heart breaks when I read stories about animals like Oreo. We don't treat these so called people the way they should be treated. If the law inforcement worked the way I'd like to see it work, these people would be treated in such a way that they would never touch another animal again. We as a society slap these horrible excuses for human beings, with nothing more than a tap on their wrists. It makes alot of us very mad, but how can we do more than we do?

Connie
    11/14/09 at 01:00 AMReply with quote#7

Sadly several million beautiful and healthy dogs are destroyed every year in our country--many are wonderful, friendly, well trained dogs and puppies that are put to death for lack of a home.  Oreo was a dog that so many people were pulling for because of all the abuse that he suffered.   In a case like this, people want to right a wrong and see this dog walk off into the sunset with a loving family.  On one hand, it was just one more unwanted dog that was being euthanized and on the other hand it was a dog that many people had an emotional investment in.  Where was Caesar Milan, the dog whisperer when we needed him?  Would that have helped?  What about the use of medication until the dog had calmed down enough to become accustomed to being around people who would not hurt him?  We will never know the answer to these and other questions but hopefully the ASPCA made the right decision.

Asha
    11/14/09 at 01:26 PMReply with quote#8

What a profoundly moving and thoughtful explanation.   Ed Sayres touched on the crucial point of it all.  The cruelty and abuse of animals and birds has been hidden from the mainstream public.   I do not know what the balance would be between too much exposure and de-sensitizing people vs sheltering them!

 
Mary
    11/14/09 at 06:31 PMReply with quote#9

Does anyone know what sentence, if any, Mr Henderson got?

Mike
    11/14/09 at 06:51 PMReply with quote#10

That man needs to go to jail!   What a loser. 

Sandra
    11/14/09 at 07:31 PMReply with quote#11

Please read below
  • some very disturbing emails re the death of Oreo,
  • a statement from Pets Alive 
  • some interesting statistics from Charity Navigator.org re the ASPCA;
  • comments from an animal behaviorist  
  • a letter to Ed Sayres, "the Decider" at the "A", pleading for Oreo's life:
 
re the matter of Oreo, the ASPCA jerked us all around, telling lies and deceiving the public and handing out vague messages about Oreo, as late as today.  I received messages from people who phoned their Bergh Hospital, saying that "Oreo has been killed" (info they were able to get only after speaking to ***EIGHT/8**** people), while other messages came in at the same time saying "NO she is still alive, until 3PM, according to info given to a NY Times reporter".
 
Shame on the ASPCA for this sham, for the execution of Oreo and for treating the animal-loving public like a bunch of fools!!!
 
The ASPCA, like HSUS and all the other money-grubbing-off-the-backs-of animals organizations, is doing what it always does...just making money to pay folks like Sayres the handsome salaries and benefits they enjoy, (think about this: @$500K/yr ...see 2007 report below), while animals like Oreo are confined to isolated cages and get destroyed when they become too much trouble or too hard to handle. They have no problem pleading poverty, (while their net worth is over $118 MILLION and they took in more than $85million in 2007), asking for our hard earned dollars and then ignoring our pleas when we want to step up to the plate and offer to take a problematic dog off their hands.  Pets Alive, a well-known animal sanctuary in Middletown, NY, tried in vain to contact the ASPCA...repeated calls, emails were ignored.  They are accustomed to dealing with dogs like Oreo and were prepared to offer her the care and nurturing she needed and deserved.  They were unsuccessful and so were we. Please read the following statement issued by Pets Alive re Oreo's execution: http://www.petsalive.com/ and their blog: http://petsalive.com/blog/2009/11/13/aspca-new-york-using-your-donations-to-murder-animals/
 

PETS ALIVE CONDEMNS NEW YORK ASPCA FOR KILLING MIRACLE DOG
RECOMMENDS WITHHOLDING SUPPORT

Oreo, a one year old Pit Bull mix, was put to death this afternoon at the New York Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to animals. Oreo was the victim of serious abuse, having been thrown from the sixth floor of a Brooklyn

roof top.

Oreo sustained two broken legs and a fractured rib in the horrific incident. She was nursed back to health. As part of her care she was “evaluated” by the ASPCA and deemed to be aggressive. Pets Alive, a Middletown, NY animal sanctuary, has spoken to volunteers and employees at the ASPCA and has questioned the methodology and results of those evaluations.

Pets Alive offered last night to accept responsibility for the rescue and rehabilitation of Oreo. Pets Alive has a thirty year history of rehabilitating animals deemed to be aggressive or unadoptable. “This is absolutely disgusting,” said Kerry Clair, Executive Co-Director of Pets Alive. “Animal organizations should not be adversaries, but when an organization that is chartered with protecting animals chooses to murder them when there are other options, they should lose the right to be called their protectors.”

We encourage supporters of the ASPCA to withhold financial support to a welfare organization that chooses murder over rehabilitation. They work for you, not the other way around,” added Matt DeAngelis, Executive Co-Director of Pets Alive.

Oreo. Truly a miracle dog. Beat all the odds. Slaughtered at the hands of the ASPCA.

CLICK HERE TO CONTINUE TO THE PETSALIVE WEBSITE

So, if in this season of giving, you want to help out worthy organizations, deserving of your generosity, think of all the animal rescues and sanctuaries that don't have enough money to send out flashy fliers or run costly, heart-wrenching advertisements on TV, with famous singers (remember Sarah Mclachlan singing "In the arms of the Angels???); give generously, give wisely!!!

ASPCA revenue from the Charity navigator.org  website: http://www.charitynavigator.org/index.cfm?bay=search.summary&orgid=3286  
 
 
Primary Revenue$74,823,316
Other Revenue$10,193,284
Total Revenue$85,016,600
  
Expenses 
Program Expenses$58,305,606
Administrative Expenses$1,154,998
Fundraising Expenses$12,268,496
Total Functional Expenses$71,729,100
  
Payments to Affiliates $0
Excess (or Deficit) for the year $13,287,500
  
Net Assets$118,465,650

Charts

Revenue/Expenses Trend

 

Contact Information

American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals
424 East 92nd Street
New York, NY 10128
tel: (800) 628-0028
EIN: 13-1623829

Contact Email
Visit Web Site

Leadership      (FYE 12/2007)

NameTitleCompensation% of Expenses
Edwin J. SayresPresident $446,8600.62%
........................................................................................................................
 
Sent: Friday, November 13, 2009 2:50 PM
Subject: Re: NYC: RIP Oreo! ASPCA Issues Statement on Euthanasia of "Oreo" *** THEY KILLED HER**
I sent Sayres a letter as a canine behaviorist, explaining that abused animals need a continuous show of attention, love and support, and that even the worst can be turned around, but it takes patience and forming a bond of trust. What did these clueless monsters expect? For Oreo NOT to be aggressive after living with a demonic psychopath who beat and attempted to murder her? After setting unrealistic standards [standards no human would be expected to live up to under the same circumstances] this poor pup was victimized once again by clueless "F"ing idiots. This little girl needed to convalesce in someone's loving home as soon after the act of cruelty as possible, where she could  come to understand that not all humans are scum; instead she was institutionalized.

Fabian Henderson needs to forcibly take a short walk off NYC's highest skyscraper and hopefully LIVE to experience the excruciating pain he inflicted -- instead, this piece of toxic garbage will continue on, polluting the Earth with his presence. There is no justice.

The people at this ASPCA are the bottom of the barrel and obviously don't understand squat about the complex emotional needs of abused non-humans. Once again, an innocent pays the ultimate price for man's lack of a brain.

 Brennan
............................................................................................
A vain plea to the ASPCA to save a precious life:
 
Dear Mr. Sayres,
 
The ASPCA will lose all credibility, donations and the respect of the public, if Oreo is killed.
 
The ASPCA has given this poor, beaten, tortured, broken soul all of 5 months, during most of which she has lived in fear, pain and isolation....and has expected her to heal completely from all that she had endured? She is still a baby,only a little more that a year old and already judged to be beyond redemption?  Not a credible explanation, considering that most of Michael Vick's vicious fighting pitbulls, condemned by your own organization, have been rehabilitated and gone on to become beloved companions and adored lap dogs!!!
 
Do you imagine that the animal loving public will accept the bullcrap in your press release explaining why she had to be killed and think you did the right thing? I don't think so!
 
I urge you to reconsider the options that have been suggested, and let this poor creature live with an eye to rehabilitation rather than execution.
 
Thank you for your compassion,
Zelda Penzel
NY, NY

--- On Fri, 11/13/09, Zelda <zpenzel@nyc.rr.com> wrote:

From: Zelda <zpenzel@nyc.rr.com>
Subject: NYC: RIP Oreo! ASPCA Issues Statement on Euthanasia of "Oreo" *** THEY KILLED HER****
To: Undisclosed-Recipient@yahoo.com
Date: Friday, November 13, 2009, 11:04 AM

RIP, Oreo!  ASPCA Issues Statement on Euthanasia of Oreo
The ASPCA gave this poor, beaten, tortured, broken soul all of 5 months, during most of which she lived in fear, pain and isolation....and they expected her to heal completely from all that she had endured??? She was still a baby, only one year old and already judged to be beyond redemption??? 
Are you able to accept this bullcrap and think they did the right thing?
 
Sent: Friday, November 13, 2009 10:53 AM


ASPCA Issues Statement on Euthanasia of Oreo

November 13, 2009

NEW YORK— The ASPCA® (The American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals®) issued a statement from President and CEO Ed Sayres prompted by today's euthanasia of Oreo, a victim of animal cruelty:

On June 18th, a one-year old Pit Bull Mix named Oreo was thrown off a 6th floor Brooklyn roof top by 19-year old Fabian Henderson.  Oreo sustained two broken legs and a fractured rib in the horrific incident.  Amidst a flurry of media coverage and public outcry, Oreo was taken to the ASPCA hospital to be treated for her injuries, and Mr. Henderson was placed under arrest by ASPCA Humane Law Enforcement Agents.

The circumstances that led to this most difficult and heartbreaking of decisions are not widely known.  In fact, details such as these are usually closely guarded.  And yet, what is even more tragic about this story's ending is that it is an all-too-familiar outcome in shelters across the country. 

It is the true face of the fight against animal cruelty.

Oreo was a victim of cruelty at the hands of Mr. Henderson.  The details surrounding these incidents are largely unknown.  However, after Mr. Henderson's arrest in July, it was learned that several of his neighbors reported hearing the sounds of the dog being beaten for at least 20-30 minutes—and the dog whimpering as a consequence.

After arriving at the ASPCA's facility, Oreo began to recuperate from her injuries, only to begin showing signs of extreme aggression—with little provocation or warning.  As is customary at the ASPCA, the dog underwent a series of comprehensive behavior evaluations.  This evaluation system has been used to assess many other dogs and is used to determine the rehabilitation programs needed to prepare them for foster care or placement.  In the case of Oreo, we also sought the assessment of an outside veterinary behaviorist.  The outcomes of these evaluations were all the same:  the dog was not able to be placed in a home.  Despite extensive behavior rehabilitation efforts undertaken by ASPCA staff, Oreo continued to lunge, growl, snap and attempt to bite.   She would lunge at a behaviorist, only to spontaneously and unpredictably redirect her aggression toward her handler.   She could not be socialized with other dogs for fear of an attack—her aggression toward other dogs was clearly evident during her evaluations.  For the safety of the individuals at the ASPCA, the other animals, and Oreo herself, she had to be kept in relative isolation, and daily contact with her was kept to a minimum of essential, and highly-trained, personnel.  In fact, employees were even directed to refrain from making sustained eye contact with Oreo so as to not incite aggression.

Because adoption was not an option, the ASPCA looked at placing Oreo in a long-term resident facility.  However, because of the aggressive behavior displayed, it is almost certain that Oreo would have lived out her entire life in seclusion from other dogs and people.   Her contact with the outside world would have been minimal at best.  Her quality of life would have been reduced to virtually nothing.  Thus, we arrived at the painful yet clear decision to humanely euthanize Oreo.

While Oreo's plight has garnered a plethora of media attention due to the sensational nature of her injuries, the decision to euthanize her is not a novel one.  These are decisions that we have had to make before—and will undoubtedly have to make again.  And as painful as these choices are, they are the same ones that face dedicated shelter workers throughout the country each and every day.   However, these outcomes are made all the more tragic because they are often preventable.

Animals that suffer cruelty at the hands of their owners often face tragedy beyond that which they have already endured.  Animals like Oreo are abused every day.  These cases often don't make headlines; in fact, most people don't even know this abuse is quietly occurring in their backyard.  But this abuse is all too frequent, and despite more rigorous efforts by law enforcement across the country, shows little sign of completely abating.

Sometimes these animals are fortunate enough to escape the confines of their abuse and are placed in loving homes.  Sometimes, they die as a result of the abuse.  And sometimes they retaliate from their abuse in the only way they know how: aggression.  It is this last unfortunate circumstance that places shelters in the precarious position in which we find ourselves now.  We have done everything humanly possible to save Oreo's life; yet, as a result of the abuse she suffered at the hands of Mr. Henderson, or for other reasons we may never know, she has come to a place where she can no longer be around people or other animals.  We make this decision—and others like it-- with a heavy heart and a complete understanding that had she been treated with love and respect, Oreo's fate would be much different.

People know that the ASPCA is in the business of saving animals’ lives-- it serves as the very core of our 143-year-old mission.  Yet, the moment this statement is picked up, we will feel the repercussions of the difficult decision we know had to be made.  We will receive angry phone calls… profanity-laced e-mails... and we will likely be vilified by tweeters and bloggers across the country.  And the rallying cry of these missives will all be the same: the ASPCA failed this animal.  If the ASPCA has failed at anything, it is shielding America from the true face of animal cruelty for far too long.  Animal cruelty isn’t pretty and doesn’t always have a happy ending—it is ugly and sad and, ultimately, tragic.  As a community of individuals committed to the welfare of animals, we have to be more proactive and insistent in raising our voices against cruelty—and hope that the nation is ready to listen. 

 
Sent: Friday, November 13, 2009 10:53 AM


ASPCA Issues Statement on Euthanasia of Oreo

November 13, 2009

NEW YORK— The ASPCA® (The American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals®) issued a statement from President and CEO Ed Sayres prompted by today's euthanasia of Oreo, a victim of animal cruelty:

On June 18th, a one-year old Pit Bull Mix named Oreo was thrown off a 6th floor Brooklyn roof top by 19-year old Fabian Henderson.  Oreo sustained two broken legs and a fractured rib in the horrific incident.  Amidst a flurry of media coverage and public outcry, Oreo was taken to the ASPCA hospital to be treated for her injuries, and Mr. Henderson was placed under arrest by ASPCA Humane Law Enforcement Agents.

The circumstances that led to this most difficult and heartbreaking of decisions are not widely known.  In fact, details such as these are usually closely guarded.  And yet, what is even more tragic about this story's ending is that it is an all-too-familiar outcome in shelters across the country. 

It is the true face of the fight against animal cruelty.

Oreo was a victim of cruelty at the hands of Mr. Henderson.  The details surrounding these incidents are largely unknown.  However, after Mr. Henderson's arrest in July, it was learned that several of his neighbors reported hearing the sounds of the dog being beaten for at least 20-30 minutes—and the dog whimpering as a consequence.

After arriving at the ASPCA's facility, Oreo began to recuperate from her injuries, only to begin showing signs of extreme aggression—with little provocation or warning.  As is customary at the ASPCA, the dog underwent a series of comprehensive behavior evaluations.  This evaluation system has been used 

 
Sent: Friday, November 13, 2009 10:53 AM


ASPCA Issues Statement on Euthanasia of Oreo

November 13, 2009

NEW YORK— The ASPCA® (The American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals®) issued a statement from President and CEO Ed Sayres prompted by today's euthanasia of Oreo, a victim of animal cruelty:

On June 18th, a one-year old Pit Bull Mix named Oreo was thrown off a 6th floor Brooklyn roof top by 19-year old Fabian Henderson.  Oreo sustained two broken legs and a fractured rib in the horrific incident.  Amidst a flurry of media coverage and public outcry, Oreo was taken to the ASPCA hospital to be treated for her injuries, and Mr. Henderson was placed under arrest by ASPCA Humane Law Enforcement Agents.

The circumstances that led to this most difficult and heartbreaking of decisions are not widely known.  In fact, details such as these are usually closely guarded.  And yet, what is even more tragic about this story's ending is that it is an all-too-familiar outcome in shelters across the country. 

It is the true face of the fight against animal cruelty.

Oreo was a victim of cruelty at the hands of Mr. Henderson.  The details surrounding these incidents are largely unknown.  However, after Mr. Henderson's arrest in July, it was learned that several of his neighbors reported hearing the sounds of the dog being beaten for at least 20-30 minutes—and the dog whimpering as a consequence.

After arriving at the ASPCA's facility, Oreo began to recuperate from her injuries, only to begin showing signs of extreme aggression—with little provocation or warning.  As is customary at the ASPCA, the dog underwent a series of comprehensive behavior evaluations.  This evaluation system has been used 

The ASPCA gave this poor, beaten, tortured, broken soul all of 5 months, during most of which she lived in fear, pain and isolation....and they expected her to heal completely from all that she had endured??? She was still a baby, only one year old and already judged to be beyond redemption??? 
Are you able to accept this bullcrap and think they did the right thing?
 
Sent: Friday, November 13, 2009 10:53 AM


ASPCA Issues Statement on Euthanasia of Oreo

November 13, 2009

NEW YORK— The ASPCA® (The American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals®) issued a statement from President and CEO Ed Sayres prompted by today's euthanasia of Oreo, a victim of animal cruelty:

On June 18th, a one-year old Pit Bull Mix named Oreo was thrown off a 6th floor Brooklyn roof top by 19-year old Fabian Henderson.  Oreo sustained two broken legs and a fractured rib in the horrific incident.  Amidst a flurry of media coverage and public outcry, Oreo was taken to the ASPCA hospital to be treated for her injuries, and Mr. Henderson was placed under arrest by ASPCA Humane Law Enforcement Agents.

The circumstances that led to this most difficult and heartbreaking of decisions are not widely known.  In fact, details such as these are usually closely guarded.  And yet, what is even more tragic about this story's ending is that it is an all-too-familiar outcome in shelters across the country. 

It is the true face of the fight against animal cruelty.

Oreo was a victim of cruelty at the hands of Mr. Henderson.  The details surrounding these incidents are largely unknown.  However, after Mr. Henderson's arrest in July, it was learned that several of his neighbors reported hearing the sounds of the dog being beaten for at least 20-30 minutes—and the dog whimpering as a consequence.

After arriving at the ASPCA's facility, Oreo began to recuperate from her injuries, only to begin showing signs of extreme aggression—with little provocation or warning.  As is customary at the ASPCA, the dog underwent a series of comprehensive behavior evaluations.  This evaluation system has been used  to assess many other dogs and is used to determine the rehabilitation programs needed to prepare them for foster care or placement.  In the case of Oreo, we also sought the assessment of an outside veterinary behaviorist.  The outcomes of these evaluations were all the same:  the dog was not able to be placed in a home.  Despite extensive behavior rehabilitation efforts undertaken by ASPCA staff, Oreo continued to lunge, growl, snap and attempt to bite.   She would lunge at a behaviorist, only to spontaneously and unpredictably redirect her aggression toward her handler.   She could not be socialized with other dogs for fear of an attack—her aggression toward other dogs was clearly evident during her evaluations.  For the safety of the individuals at the ASPCA, the other animals, and Oreo herself, she had to be kept in relative isolation, and daily contact with her was kept to a minimum of essential, and highly-trained, personnel.  In fact, employees were even directed to refrain from making sustained eye contact with Oreo so as to not incite aggression.

Because adoption was not an option, the ASPCA looked at placing Oreo in a long-term resident facility.  However, because of the aggressive behavior displayed, it is almost certain that Oreo would have lived out her entire life in seclusion from other dogs and people.   Her contact with the outside world would have been minimal at best.  Her quality of life would have been reduced to virtually nothing.  Thus, we arrived at the painful yet clear decision to humanely euthanize Oreo.

While Oreo's plight has garnered a plethora of media attention due to the sensational nature of her injuries, the decision to euthanize her is not a novel one.  These are decisions that we have had to make before—and will undoubtedly have to make again.  And as painful as these choices are, they are the same ones that face dedicated shelter workers throughout the country each and every day.   However, these outcomes are made all the more tragic because they are often preventable.

Animals that suffer cruelty at the hands of their owners often face tragedy beyond that which they have already endured.  Animals like Oreo are abused every day.  These cases often don't make headlines; in fact, most people don't even know this abuse is quietly occurring in their backyard.  But this abuse is all too frequent, and despite more rigorous efforts by law enforcement across the country, shows little sign of completely abating.

Sometimes these animals are fortunate enough to escape the confines of their abuse and are placed in loving homes.  Sometimes, they die as a result of the abuse.  And sometimes they retaliate from their abuse in the only way they know how: aggression.  It is this last unfortunate circumstance that places shelters in the precarious position in which we find ourselves now.  We have done everything humanly possible to save Oreo's life; yet, as a result of the abuse she suffered at the hands of Mr. Henderson, or for other reasons we may never know, she has come to a place where she can no longer be around people or other animals.  We make this decision—and others like it-- with a heavy heart and a complete understanding that had she been treated with love and respect, Oreo's fate would be much different.

People know that the ASPCA is in the business of saving animals’ lives-- it serves as the very core of our 143-year-old mission.  Yet, the moment this statement is picked up, we will feel the repercussions of the difficult decision we know had to be made.  We will receive angry phone calls… profanity-laced e-mails... and we will likely be vilified by tweeters and bloggers across the country.  And the rallying cry of these missives will all be the same: the ASPCA failed this animal.  If the ASPCA has failed at anything, it is shielding America from the true face of animal cruelty for far too long.  Animal cruelty isn’t pretty and doesn’t always have a happy ending—it is ugly and sad and, ultimately, tragic.  As a community of individuals committed to the welfare of animals, we have to be more proactive and insistent in raising our voices against cruelty—and hope that the nation is ready to listen.

###
Founded in 1866, the ASPCA® (The American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals®) is the first humane organization established in the Americas and serves as the nation’s leading voice for animal welfare. One million supporters strong, the ASPCA’s mission is to provide effective means for the prevention of cruelty to animals throughout the United States. As a 501 [c] [3] not-for-profit corporation, the ASPCA is a national leader in the areas of anti-cruelty, community outreach and animal health services. The ASPCA, which is headquartered in New York City, offers a wide range of programs, including a mobile clinic outreach initiative, its own humane law enforcement team, and a groundbreaking veterinary forensics team and mobile animal CSI unit. For more information, please visit
http://www.aspca.org.

Note contact info below.  Please participate and forward to any NY contacts you might have.  Thanks. 

 
From: Centcom
To: undisclosed-recipients
Sent: Thursday, November 12, 2009 10:57 PM
Subject: URGENT - ACTION NEEDED - Oreo Scheduled for Execution by ASPCA on Friday 11/13

Friends/Comrades....please help us to save the life of this poor dog. We have inside information and we believe that the story being given is distorted.  This dog can and should be saved.  Please consider writing and cross posting this info as widely as you can and as quickly as possible.  Oreo only has hours left to live.

Camille

****Cross Post Freely, Widely & Quickly****

OREO - ONLY HOURS LEFT TO LIVE



ASPCA
WILL EXECUTE OREO
ON FRIDAY THE 13TH


"WHY IS ED SAYRES, CEO - ASPCA, LYING?"


On November 3, 2009 in a WAR action alert, we asked the question "what ever happened to Oreo", the young dog (i year old) that was thrown from the rooftop of a 6 story Brooklyn building?   Many of you wrote to the ASPCA and many of you forwarded the ASPCA's written replies to WAR.  Mr. Sayres tell those who wrote that Oreo is doing well, still healing and that a decision has not been made about what to do next. 

Now the whole ugly truth is starting to come out, as the ASPCA frantically tries to spin the story, in a way that will protect the ASPCA from scrutiny. See the New York Times story that was just published:

http://www.nytimes.com/2009/11/13/nyregion/13oreo.html

You can post a comment to the NY Times article and we encourage you to do so, as we are sure that the ASPCA will be reading those comments.

Please write to or phone Ed Sayres immediately. Ask them not to kill Oreo and to find a suitable rescue or rehabber for her. 

Mr. Ed Sayres
President & CEO
American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (ASPCA)
424 E. 92nd St
New York, NY 10128-6804

e-mail:  esayres@aspca.org
 
Telephone:  1-212-876-7700 Ext. 4600

His secretary, Christine is at:  1-212-876-7700 ext. 4600

After 7:00 am on Friday, November 13th you can call: 1-212-876-7700 extension 2500 and ask to speak to the person in charge.

Following is an open letter to Mr. Sayres from Win Animal Rights:

Open Letter to Ed Sayres:

Dear Mr. Sayres,

I represent the animal rights/animal liberation group Win Animal Rights based here in New York City.  Win Animal Rights has both national and international affiliations.  It was at our invitation that many activists contacted you at the ASPCA to ask about the status of the young pit bull that was thrown from a Brooklyn roof and "rescued" by the ASPCA.  Many of our readers have forwarded your responses to us.  Many initially believed the misleading information you sent them.  Mr. Sayres, why are you lying to people?

We both know that the implication, in your e-mail responses, that you are holding Oreo until the end of the criminal action against Fabian Henderson, is untrue.  Mr. Henderson relinquished ownership of Oreo to the ASPCA many months ago.  If you had to hold her for legal reasons, why is it that you have given the order to kill her on Friday, November 13th?

We both know that Oreo is not still healing. If anything Oreo is now suffering from emotional abuse that she has suffered since being "rescued" by the ASPCA.  She has sat in a cage with very limited human interaction. She wears an elizabethan collar 24 hours a day, seven days a week.....not because she needs it, but, because it makes her easier for your people to handle.  This alone would make a dog crazy.  How can you be so cruel?

Speaking of cruel, no doubt the ASPCA had the best of intentions when you "rescued" Oreo and put her through extensive surgery and a lengthy and painful convalescence, or did it have something to do with the media attention on the story and the thousands of dollars that have been received in donations for Oreo?  Do Oreo's donors know that you are about to execute her?  How do you think they would feel about their donation dollars being wasted and more donation dollars used to put her to death?

Why is it that you did not report, to those who wrote, about the ASPCA behaviorist advocating that Oreo was, in her opinion,  aggressive and a liability and that she could not be rehomed?  Why is it that you did not tell anyone that a second behaviorist has since been brought in (as ignorant as the first) to support the ASPCA's decision to kill Oreo?  Did you think you could keep this information from the public?

How is it that you tell some that Oreo is getting plenty of daily human interaction when you tell others that she is vicious and cannot be handled by anyone?  Seems like you are getting caught in the web of your own lies.  Is Oreo vicious and unable to be handled, as your behaviorist claims, or is she getting plenty of love and human interaction? 

It has been reported to Win Animal Rights, that the decision to kill Oreo was made some time ago and that only the ASPCA's fear of negative publicity has kept you from executing her so far.  If negative publicity is a deterrent to killing, we would be happy to provide you with all of the negative publicity you can handle.

This letter and the facts of the case are being broadcast to every journalist, every blogger, every social networking venue and every animal friendly list in the world.  If Oreo is executed, we will not forgive you and we will never forget such a shameless act of betrayal.  You have my personal word on that.

Every individual life is precious.  Please live up to your name, American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals and your mission statement.  If the ASPCA cannot rehabilitate Oreo and undo the damage of over 5 months in solitude in an ASPCA cage, at least find a group that can help Oreo.   We both know that there are rescue groups and sanctuaries that work with dogs with behavioral problems.  I am sure they would be happy to release the ASPCA from all legal liability.  We would be anxious to assist you in finding an appropriate rescue.  You can reach me at: centcom@war-online.org

Until all are free,

Camille Hankins
Founder/Director
Win Animal Rights
http://war-online.org

Press Officer
North American Animal Liberation Press Office
http://animalliberationpressoffice.org


If you have any questions, comments or suggestions feel free to contact us at: centcom@war-online.org

Visit the WAR Calendar for future events: http://calendar.yahoo.com/winanimalrights
Visit the WAR MySpace page:  http://www.myspace.com/winanimalrights
Visit WAR on Facebook: http://www.facebook.com/pages/Win-Animal-Rights/25169195791

For more info contact Win Animal Rights at: winanimalrights@optonline.net
Call: 646.267.9934 or visit the WAR website at: http://war-online.org
W.A.R. (WIN ANIMAL RIGHTS) is an independent non-profit organization not affiliated or associated with SHAC, SHAC USA or any other group or organization and does not conduct or incite any illegal activity. The above information is not meant to incite or request any illegal actions or illegal activities of any kind.  If you have any questions about the legality of any act, we encourage everyone receiving this (or the) action alert(s) to check your local laws and ordinances before proceeding to do anything.
 
aag
    11/14/09 at 08:25 PMReply with quote#12

I still question the decision....the ASPCA has a long history of suspicious behavior...and I only pray this was the only decision. I wonder, if other sources...The Dog Whisperer, Train of Thought, or any of the myriad organizations could have found a better way to deal with poor Oreo....the pain and suffering are over...now...and I guess that is something at least.

Monika Courtney, Colorado
    11/15/09 at 07:27 AMReply with quote#13

To whom it may concern:
 
Your atrocious and inhumane act on the dog Oreo is a deplorable act of selfishness. I would believe Mike Arms would not be proud of your organization now. For all he's worked so hard to make changes for the better, he left to implement even more changes for the animal welfare... of which you should take a crash course urgently.
 
What is wrong with this ? Has your leadership no compassion or even the slightest respect to save lives, specially under such dire circumstances ?? Is the ASPCA's fear of failing in successfully rehabilitating this dog and ensure a future for her as should be your utmost priority.. is that fear greater than your concern to give her THAT very chance with another organization ? How dare you make such an atrocious and inhumane decision ?
 
Are you joining the propagandists of other big names in animal welfare whose main interests are to gain financially with national ad and mailing campaigns under the guise of "helping animals that need rescue" ???
 
You ought to be forever ashamed of your cowardly act. It just seems the ASPCA is still in the stone age when it comes to effective and fair assessment testing under which so many animals die because the humans in charge are self-appointed "experts" with no clue.  
 
You could gain much insight from checking these links:
 
 
 
 
 
The methods presently applied in your organization are the doom of any animal in question... they are outdated, unfair and absolutely provocatively giving you an excuse to kill.
 
In modern America, under a name of your caliber, the killing of Oreo is unacceptable. Your publicity gig towards collecting donations from unsuspecting people and your heartless act of "judgement" in this case are an outrage. The media ought to report on this - to expose your failure to put the animal first.
 
Oreo has suffered tremendously and deserved more from you. Your shortsightedness and unprofessional practices must be exposed. And I suggest you educate yourself and your staff on how to be more humane, save lives and make that a top priority by attending a workshop at Mike Arm's Animal Center in California.
Animals always become victims of twisted propaganda.. when it is about saving the image of the powers in charge.. Shame on you.
 
Monika Courtney, Colorado
myth of unmanageable dogs
    11/15/09 at 01:51 PMReply with quote#14

Destroying dogs because they are said to be unmanageable is another lie created by organizations like the aspca who in actuality can't be bothered to find someone to take such a problem animal. This killing of aggressive dogs is routine. if you've ever watched 'animal cops' on television you will see it occurring across the country at dog shelters.
where is cesare milan, the dog trainer? he has shown that no dog will remain unmanagable if rehabilitated properly--this is a myth perpetuated by ignorance.
Someone ask him for his opinion on this matter. He specializes in rehabbing pit bulls.
Shame on the aspca who is always issuing statements that don't amount to a pile of beans. Qualified rehabbers need to work with the aspca to see that these animals aren't needlessly killed. If they told the truth I would respect them more, but they have to cover everything over with some treacly sounding bullshit.

cuteus
    11/15/09 at 02:29 PMReply with quote#15

The NY Times article is not accepting any more comments.
The ASPCA does have a high tech hospital in NYC and I would hate to see that service suffer because revenue is withheld, but I support letting them know of our concerns for their assessment practices, strongly encouraging them to review their procedures and protocols to ensure that they have actually done all that could be done.  This includes allowing other groups to step in and take responsibility for the animal. 
I have been disturbed by the show Animal Precint, the episodes that show the staff in the process of assessing a dog for their potential for rehabilitation. Some of their techniques i would not use with my own animals because they seem unnecessarily aggressive/provoking in nature. Grabbing their food bowl while they eat, dangling weird hands in their faces, these things would disturb even me, let alone a traumatized dog.  5 months is not long enough for an abused dog to show what they can become, they would not expect a human with mental disorders to respond in that short period of time! 
I support the legal team of the ASPCA, going after abusers; and the great job done in their magnificent hospital ( I still recall the life saving behavior by one of their vets in saving a "no pulse" puppy brought to their facility, the extreme measures taken by the vet).  It is these extreme measures that I want to see in dealing with mental injuries. 
We need to contact the organization and demand that they review their practices if they are to continue receiving our financial support.  We have to demand and give them a chance to change, before putting the animals currently in their care in jeopardy by withdrawing our donations. Think of them.  Demand a change.

AND, if you are one of those neighbors, hearing a beating for 20 to 30 minutes, GET involved and call the police! My gosh! If these neighbors would have acted from the get go, Oreo would have had a  better shot at life.  GET INVOLVED before it gets worse. BE a nosy neighbor for goodness sake.  Things would have been different for Oreo and the animals in the recent abuse case in Selden, Long Island. 
We have to address everyone's responsibility, starting with the human in the mirror.

I am now copying this letter to the ASPCA, trying to avoind another Oreo.
Ivette

Previous Thread | Next Thread
Page 1 of 2   1  |  2 > 
Reply

  Bookmarks  
Digg DiggFacebook Facebookdel.icio.us del.icio.usStumbleUpon StumbleUponGoogle Google
Twitter TwitterWindows Live Favorites Windows Live FavoritesTechnorati Tags Technorati Tagsreddit reddit

communication: bestbirdclub@yahoo.com
disclaimer: we do not verify the accuracy of your posting and assume no responsibility for its content.